Types Of Peer Review Review - 1158 Words

Types of peer review There are different journals which follow different types of peer review, based on the kind of research they publish as well as their journal management style. The single and double-blinded peer reviews are the most commonly adopted by many journals. In the single-blind review, the reviewer is aware of the author’s identity, but not vice versa. In the double-blind review, both the author and reviewer are not aware of the other’s identity. In the recent time, some academic journals have started adopting two other kinds of peer reviews called open and post-publication peer review. In the open review system, the identity of the author and reviewers is known, and this system may allow the comments made by the peer reviewer as well as authors’ responses to be published along with the final version of the manuscript. The post-publication peer review is a relatively new trend adopted by some open access publications in which reviewers evaluate a manuscript after it has been published on an open access platform. At this time, the identity of the author and the reviewer is known (published), and so is the peer review evaluation of the manuscript. This system may allow reviewers to get credit for their reviews (Rajagopalan, 2014). As seen by Ware and Monkman (2008), the double-blind review was the most effective approach appreciated by authors (71%), followed by single-blind (52%), post-publication (37%) and open peer review (26%). Through a deep chronical reviewShow MoreRelatedWhat Is Peer Review?960 Words   |  4 PagesThe literature review What is peer review? Peer review is the evaluation of scholarly and academic articles by other researchers or scientists who are expert in the field and qualified enough to perform a reasonably neutral review. It is an indispensable part of the process of the scholarly publication. Most academic journals rely on scholarly peer review, or refereeing, to help editors evaluate the quality of articles submitted to their journals. The review process is a skill, which is learnedRead MoreScholarly Journals Versus Popular Magazines876 Words   |  4 PagesAssociation ) to introduce the article authors and the public date. Expert(scholar, professor, researcher,etc) in field covered. Author is always named. For example: â€Å"modeling habitual and addictive smart-phone behavior: the role of smart-phone usage types, emotional intelligence, social stress, self-regulation,age, and gender(Alexander J.A.M. Van Deursen’, et.al, 2015)† This in order to make the statement of the article more specifically. For the magazines, journalist , nonprofessional or laypersonRead MoreThe Need For Peer Review Evaluation System1371 Words   |  6 PagesPeer Evaluation System Introduction The need for peer review evaluation system helps in evaluating the work done by different students, who poses the same level of competency. Through this method, it is possible to set out the standards for quality check, which is required for improving the performance. The demand for academic review across different universities has increased. This helps the students to conduct a detailed analysis of the situation or the project that has been carriedRead MorePeer Review825 Words   |  4 PagesENGL112 Peer Review Worksheet INSTRUCTIONS: Peer Reviews will be conducted in class discussion forums during Week 7. Be sure to review the Lecture and the Discussion area for additional details and guidance. Please complete the following steps below, returning a separate peer review worksheet for each of the two classmates whose papers you review. This assignment is worth 50 points. * You will receive 10 points for submitting your draft by the required deadline. * You will receive 20 pointsRead MoreUtilization Review ( Ur ) Can Constitute Practicing Medicine1157 Words   |  5 PagesIn some way, Utilization Review (UR) can constitute â€Å"practicing medicine† because UR is an evaluated healthcare services based on standards of care, treatment guidelines, and evidence-base medicine (Wolter, Beeman, Lynch, n.d.). The provider must address UR in the proposed decision. UR is a system designed for monitoring, evaluating and efficiency for services provided. UR should not be limited to only medical professionals licensed to practice medicine. Any provider, licensed or unlicensedRead MoreNrs-433v Week 1 Literature Search: Prevention of Surgical Site Infection1272 Words   |  6 PagesSite Infection Details: Conduct a literature search to locate research articles focused on a practice problem of interest. This literature search should include both quantitative and qualitative peer research articles to support your practice problem or issue of interest in 350-750 words. Identify six peer research articles which will be utilized through the next 5 weeks as reference sources. Create a reference list in which the six articles are listed. Beneath each reference include the articlesRead MoreUsing Skepticism to Acquire Knowledge1033 Words   |  4 Pagesbeing a skeptic is one of the key ways in which scientist acquire knowledge. In the scientific process one of the fundamental steps in which scientist rely on to acquire knowledge is peer review. Peer review is done due to the idea of being skeptical on a knowledge claim in which someone published. In the peer review step scientist ask for clarity in definitions, check consistency in the logic (like the mathematical process or logical justifications), and check the adequacy of the evidence (like theRead MoreData Evaluation with CARS Checklist: Factors That Affect Student Success in Nursing School1762 Words   |  7 PagesMoore, G. (2007). Baccalaureate nursing program admission policies: Promoting succes s or facilitating failure? Journal of Nursing Education,46(10), 439-444. Olson, M.A. (2012). English-as-a-second-language (ESL) nursing student success: A critical review of the literature. Journal of Cultural Diversity, 19(1), 26-32. Patchell, B. (2005). Mentoring in multiple dimensions. Journal of Cultural Diversity, 12(2), 56-58. Rogers, T.L. (2010). Prescription for success in an associate degree nursing programRead MorePerformance Appraisal : Performance Evaluation1275 Words   |  6 PagesYearly performance reviews are a key part of many workplaces across the country and is an instrumental way for employers to document employees performance throughout the past year. These performance reviews also provide employees with the knowledge off what they have done well and what they should try to improve on. However, there are multiple other ways in which performance reviews can be utilized and numerous types of reviews that can be used. â€Å"Performance appraisal can be viewed as the processRead MorePeer Assessment At The Heart Of Formative Assessment Essay1695 Words   |  7 Pages2. Review of Related Literature 2.1. Peer Feedback Peer assessment lies at the heart of formative assessment. Using peer feedback in writing classrooms enables students learn from their peer and support each other. (Carless, 2011) This goes in line with Vygotsky’s (1978) social-interactionist view which claimed that students learn better when they interact with their peers. Although there are concerns that students may not be able to assess their peers as reliable as their teacher, Carless (2011)